Supreme Court Deadlocks on Religious Charter School Funding Battle

Article arrow_drop_down
Supreme Court Deadlocks on Religious Charter School Funding Battle

The United States Supreme Court reached a deadlock Thursday in a case determining whether a religious charter school in Oklahoma should receive public funding.

The tie vote allows a lower court ruling to stand. Previously, Oklahoma’s state Supreme Court had blocked government funding for the St Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School, citing constitutional separation of church and state provisions.

However, the Supreme Court’s split decision leaves the door open for similar cases. Without a definitive ruling from the nation’s highest court, no new precedent governs funding for charter schools, which are independent institutions receiving government support.

Supreme Court tie votes are uncommon. The Houston Law Review estimated only 183 ties occurred since 1791 among over 28,000 cases. The court typically has nine justices to prevent even splits.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett recused herself from the hearings. While she provided no explanation, this likely stemmed from her close relationship with St Isidore adviser Nicole Garnett. The two clerked together at the Supreme Court in the late 1990s and later taught together at the University of Notre Dame. When Trump nominated Barrett in 2020, Garnett praised her friend in USA Today, describing their lives as “completely intertwined.”

The court’s announcement acknowledged Barrett’s absence: “The judgment is affirmed by an equally divided Court. JUSTICE BARRETT took no part in the consideration or decision of these cases.”

This created a 4-4 split, though the precise alignment wasn’t disclosed. Chief Justice Roberts likely joined the three liberal justices in opposing the school’s government funding.

The Supreme Court currently maintains a conservative supermajority with six right-leaning justices. Previously, the court has shown receptiveness to expanding religious freedoms, including cases testing the Constitution’s Establishment Clause, which prohibits government “establishment of religion.”

The Oklahoma case began in 2023 when the Catholic Archdiocese of Oklahoma City applied to open a taxpayer-funded charter school teaching Catholic doctrine. This would have been the first publicly funded religious school, offering online education from kindergarten through high school with plans to open in 2024.

The Oklahoma Statewide Virtual Charter School Board initially rejected the proposal in April but approved it 3-2 in June, creating a legal battle. Opponents argued this violated church-state separation, while supporters claimed blocking the school restricted religious freedom.

The proposal divided Oklahoma’s Republican leadership. Attorney General Gentner Drummond opposed it as “state-funded religion,” while Governor Kevin Stitt supported the plan.

In Oklahoma, like most states, charter schools are part of the public system. When the case reached Oklahoma’s Supreme Court in 2024, this distinction proved crucial. The court struck down St Isidore 6-2, ruling that state funding would make it a “surrogate of the state” like other charter schools.

The judges determined the school would “require students to spend time in religious instruction and activities, as well as permit state spending in direct support of the religious curriculum and activities โ€” all in violation of the establishment clause.”

The school’s supporters appealed to the Supreme Court, leading to April arguments. Conservative justices seemed favorable to St Isidore’s case. Justice Brett Kavanaugh argued that denying taxpayer funds appeared to be “rank discrimination against religion,” stating, “All the religious school is saying is, ‘Don’t exclude us on account of our religion.'”

Liberal justices warned that ruling for St Isidore could transform public schools into religious institutions, creating a precedent requiring government funding for all faith-based education.

The American Civil Liberties Union, backing a separate lawsuit against the school, celebrated Thursday’s deadlock as protecting church-state separation. “The very idea of a religious public school is a constitutional oxymoron,” said Daniel Mach, director of the ACLU’s Program on Freedom of Religion and Belief.

Proponents vowed to continue fighting. Jim Campbell, who argued for St Isidore on behalf of Oklahoma’s charter school board, noted the court might “revisit the issue in the future” given the deadlock. “Oklahoma parents and children are better off with more educational choices, not fewer,” he said.

About the author

Trump Threatens New Russia Sanctions As Ukraine War Drags On
trending_flat
Trump Threatens New Russia Sanctions As Ukraine War Drags On

President Donald Trump expressed dissatisfaction with Vladimir Putin over the ongoing Ukraine conflict and indicated he may impose additional sanctions on Russia. "We get a lot of b******t thrown at us by Putin," Trump stated during a White House cabinet meeting Tuesday. "He's very nice all the time, but it turns out to be meaningless." Trump noted that Putin is "killing a lot of people," including both Russian soldiers and Ukrainian forces. When questioned about Senate-proposed legislation for further Russian sanctions, Trump responded: "I'm looking at it very strongly." However, Trump declined to elaborate on his plans regarding Putin, telling reporters: "I wouldn't be telling you. Don't we want to have a little surprise?" He then shifted the discussion to last month's US strikes against Iran's nuclear facilities. These remarks coincided with French President Emmanuel Macron's address to the British […]

Israel Strikes Deep Into Lebanon Killing Three Despite Ceasefire Agreement
trending_flat
Israel Strikes Deep Into Lebanon Killing Three Despite Ceasefire Agreement

An Israeli strike on a vehicle near the northern Lebanese city of Tripoli has killed at least three people and injured 13 others, according to Lebanon's Health Ministry, marking another violation of the ceasefire between the two countries. The attack occurred Tuesday in the Ayrounieh area as Israel continues striking Lebanon despite Hezbollah's weakened state, the Lebanese army's limited capacity to respond, and the international community's inability to enforce the truce. The strike near Lebanon's northernmost major city, located more than 180km from the Israeli border, demonstrates Israel's readiness to conduct operations throughout the country beyond southern regions. The Israeli military stated it targeted a "key" figure from Hamas without providing identification. However, a Hamas source in Lebanon told Al Araby TV that no senior official from the group was killed in the strike. Lebanon's Annahar newspaper reported that initial […]

UK Threatens New Action Against Israel If Gaza Ceasefire Fails
trending_flat
UK Threatens New Action Against Israel If Gaza Ceasefire Fails

British Foreign Secretary David Lammy has criticized the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and indicated that the United Kingdom could take additional measures against Israel if a ceasefire agreement fails to materialize. During testimony before Parliament's Foreign Affairs Committee on Tuesday, Lammy also condemned the new aid distribution system in Gaza operated by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), a group supported by the United States and Israel. "We've been very clear that we don't support the aid foundation that has been set up," Lammy stated. "It's not doing a good job. Too many people are close to starvation. Too many people have lost their lives. We have led globally on our condemnation the system that has been set up." Recent weeks have seen hundreds of Palestinians killed by Israeli fire while seeking GHF assistance. When asked by a legislator whether the […]

Putin Minister Found Dead Hours After Firing Sends Shockwaves Through Russia
trending_flat
Putin Minister Found Dead Hours After Firing Sends Shockwaves Through Russia

Monday brought dramatic developments to Russia as President Vladimir Putin dismissed Transport Minister Roman Starovoit, only for the former minister to be found dead with a gunshot wound to the head that same afternoon. Starovoit's body was discovered in a park near Moscow alongside a pistol. Investigators concluded he had taken his own life, marking what the tabloid Moskovsky Komsomolets called "an almost unique occurrence in Russian history." Such incidents are exceptionally rare in Russia's modern era. The last comparable case occurred over three decades ago in August 1991, when Soviet Interior Minister Boris Pugo shot himself following the failed communist coup. The Kremlin has provided limited comment on Starovoit's death. When asked about the incident, Putin's spokesman Dmitry Peskov acknowledged the shock, stating "Normal people cannot but be shocked by this. Of course, this shocked us, too." He deferred […]

Woman Convicted Of Mushroom Murder After Deadly Family Lunch
trending_flat
Woman Convicted Of Mushroom Murder After Deadly Family Lunch

An Australian woman has been convicted of murdering three family members by serving them a meal containing poisonous mushrooms. Erin Patterson was found guilty Monday on three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder following a 10-week trial in Morwell, a regional town approximately 152km east of Melbourne. The 50-year-old displayed no visible reaction as the verdicts were delivered in court. Patterson's estranged in-laws, Donald and Gail Patterson, along with Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, died after consuming beef Wellingtons containing death cap mushrooms during a lunch on July 29, 2023. Heather's husband Ian Wilkinson was also poisoned but survived after a seven-week hospitalization. Patterson had entered not guilty pleas to all charges. Her defense team argued that she had accidentally served the contaminated food to her relatives in what they characterized as a "terrible accident." Prosecutors did not […]

Shocking Coroner Report Exposes Racist Police Officer in Fatal Indigenous Teen Shooting
trending_flat
Shocking Coroner Report Exposes Racist Police Officer in Fatal Indigenous Teen Shooting

A landmark coronial inquiry has found that the Australian police officer who fatally shot an Indigenous teenager was racist and attracted to "high adrenaline policing." The 682-page findings were released Monday in Yuendumu, central Australia, revealing that racist behavior was "normalised" at Zachary Rolfe's Alice Springs police station. The conclusions came five years after the shooting of 19-year-old Kumanjayi Walker, which sparked nationwide protests. Rolfe was acquitted of murder charges in a 2022 trial in Darwin. Walker was shot three times during an attempted arrest in Yuendumu. He was among 598 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who have died in custody since detailed records began in 1991. "I found that Mr Rolfe was racist," declared Northern Territory coroner Elisabeth Armitage after a nearly three-year inquiry. She determined that Rolfe, dismissed from the police force in 2023 for unrelated reasons, […]

Related

Trump Threatens New Russia Sanctions As Ukraine War Drags On
trending_flat
Trump Threatens New Russia Sanctions As Ukraine War Drags On

President Donald Trump expressed dissatisfaction with Vladimir Putin over the ongoing Ukraine conflict and indicated he may impose additional sanctions on Russia. "We get a lot of b******t thrown at us by Putin," Trump stated during a White House cabinet meeting Tuesday. "He's very nice all the time, but it turns out to be meaningless." Trump noted that Putin is "killing a lot of people," including both Russian soldiers and Ukrainian forces. When questioned about Senate-proposed legislation for further Russian sanctions, Trump responded: "I'm looking at it very strongly." However, Trump declined to elaborate on his plans regarding Putin, telling reporters: "I wouldn't be telling you. Don't we want to have a little surprise?" He then shifted the discussion to last month's US strikes against Iran's nuclear facilities. These remarks coincided with French President Emmanuel Macron's address to the British […]

Israel Strikes Deep Into Lebanon Killing Three Despite Ceasefire Agreement
trending_flat
Israel Strikes Deep Into Lebanon Killing Three Despite Ceasefire Agreement

An Israeli strike on a vehicle near the northern Lebanese city of Tripoli has killed at least three people and injured 13 others, according to Lebanon's Health Ministry, marking another violation of the ceasefire between the two countries. The attack occurred Tuesday in the Ayrounieh area as Israel continues striking Lebanon despite Hezbollah's weakened state, the Lebanese army's limited capacity to respond, and the international community's inability to enforce the truce. The strike near Lebanon's northernmost major city, located more than 180km from the Israeli border, demonstrates Israel's readiness to conduct operations throughout the country beyond southern regions. The Israeli military stated it targeted a "key" figure from Hamas without providing identification. However, a Hamas source in Lebanon told Al Araby TV that no senior official from the group was killed in the strike. Lebanon's Annahar newspaper reported that initial […]

UK Threatens New Action Against Israel If Gaza Ceasefire Fails
trending_flat
UK Threatens New Action Against Israel If Gaza Ceasefire Fails

British Foreign Secretary David Lammy has criticized the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and indicated that the United Kingdom could take additional measures against Israel if a ceasefire agreement fails to materialize. During testimony before Parliament's Foreign Affairs Committee on Tuesday, Lammy also condemned the new aid distribution system in Gaza operated by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), a group supported by the United States and Israel. "We've been very clear that we don't support the aid foundation that has been set up," Lammy stated. "It's not doing a good job. Too many people are close to starvation. Too many people have lost their lives. We have led globally on our condemnation the system that has been set up." Recent weeks have seen hundreds of Palestinians killed by Israeli fire while seeking GHF assistance. When asked by a legislator whether the […]

Putin Minister Found Dead Hours After Firing Sends Shockwaves Through Russia
trending_flat
Putin Minister Found Dead Hours After Firing Sends Shockwaves Through Russia

Monday brought dramatic developments to Russia as President Vladimir Putin dismissed Transport Minister Roman Starovoit, only for the former minister to be found dead with a gunshot wound to the head that same afternoon. Starovoit's body was discovered in a park near Moscow alongside a pistol. Investigators concluded he had taken his own life, marking what the tabloid Moskovsky Komsomolets called "an almost unique occurrence in Russian history." Such incidents are exceptionally rare in Russia's modern era. The last comparable case occurred over three decades ago in August 1991, when Soviet Interior Minister Boris Pugo shot himself following the failed communist coup. The Kremlin has provided limited comment on Starovoit's death. When asked about the incident, Putin's spokesman Dmitry Peskov acknowledged the shock, stating "Normal people cannot but be shocked by this. Of course, this shocked us, too." He deferred […]

trending_flat
High Court to Decide Fate of Controversial Wimbledon Expansion Plans

A legal challenge against the All England Club's ambitious expansion plans for Wimbledon will be heard at the High Court on Tuesday, marking a critical moment in a four-year dispute over the future of a historic London site. Save Wimbledon Park (SWP) is contesting the Greater London Authority's approval of proposals to nearly triple the tennis venue's size by constructing 39 new courts and an 8,000-seat stadium on the former Wimbledon Park Golf Club grounds. The development received planning permission last year from Jules Pipe, London's Deputy Mayor for Planning, who determined that the project's benefits would "clearly outweigh the harm." Debbie Jevans, chair of the All England Club, highlighted that the expansion would create 27 acres of "newly accessible parkland for the community" and enable the qualifying tournament to move from Roehampton to the main site. However, the campaign […]

Woman Convicted Of Mushroom Murder After Deadly Family Lunch
trending_flat
Woman Convicted Of Mushroom Murder After Deadly Family Lunch

An Australian woman has been convicted of murdering three family members by serving them a meal containing poisonous mushrooms. Erin Patterson was found guilty Monday on three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder following a 10-week trial in Morwell, a regional town approximately 152km east of Melbourne. The 50-year-old displayed no visible reaction as the verdicts were delivered in court. Patterson's estranged in-laws, Donald and Gail Patterson, along with Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, died after consuming beef Wellingtons containing death cap mushrooms during a lunch on July 29, 2023. Heather's husband Ian Wilkinson was also poisoned but survived after a seven-week hospitalization. Patterson had entered not guilty pleas to all charges. Her defense team argued that she had accidentally served the contaminated food to her relatives in what they characterized as a "terrible accident." Prosecutors did not […]

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

โœ–

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

โœ–

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

โœ–

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation

โœ–